Chapter 13. A Lodge at Long Last

There is no place for the Sexton to live in in consequence of which, the gates have been forced open twice and cattle have been turned into the cemetery grounds.
— Trustees’ report to the Colonial Treasurer, 27 February 1856

The idea of a residence for cemetery officers pre-dated the opening of the cemetery itself. In April 1855 several months before the first burial took place, the trustees resolved that the sexton and keeper should each receive salaries of £100 per annum together with “a home to live in and provided with wood and water”. Provision was also made for the construction of a lodge and trustees’ office, and government assistance was sought towards the cost of establishing the cemetery. Although the trustees estimated that more than £2,600 would be required to fence the grounds, construct buildings and complete essential works, they received only £400, restricted to fencing purposes. The lodge therefore became one of the first ambitions sacrificed to the cemetery’s limited finances. Unable to provide the intended lodge, the trustees instead erected a small wooden building during 1856 as a temporary measure. It provided limited accommodation but did not resolve the need for a resident sexton. 1

The earliest argument for a sexton’s residence was not convenience but protection. By February 1856 only a few months after the cemetery had opened, trustees were already complaining that “there is no place for the Sexton to live in” and reported that the gates had been forced open twice and cattle had entered the cemetery grounds. They also noted that the clergy had no place to robe, the sexton had nowhere to store his tools, and the trustees themselves lacked office accommodation. In April 1856 they sought a further government advance, proposing that part of the funds be used for “the erection of a Lodge for the Sexton to reside in” together with accommodation for ministers officiating at burials. From the cemetery’s earliest years, a residence was viewed as an essential part of proper management rather than a personal benefit. 2

The lack of a residence affected both Levi Marsh and his successor, John Hooton. The connection between accommodation and effective management was recognised from an early date. Reporting to the President of Public Lands and Works in February 1858, the trustees lamented that they were still unable to provide a lodge for the sexton or employ him continuously, and complained that the cemetery had fallen into a “disgraceful Condition”. A further application for government assistance was unsuccessful, the Treasury advising that no funds were available for an additional loan. Without accommodation on site, the sexton could not devote all of his time to cemetery duties and was often obliged to seek additional employment elsewhere. Trustees repeatedly noted that a resident sexton would be able to give undivided attention to the cemetery, maintain regular oversight of the grounds and respond more readily to the needs of visitors and funeral parties. The question of a residence therefore became closely linked to the working conditions and effectiveness of the cemetery’s caretaker. 3

The lack of a residence directly affected the trustees’ ability to retain a sexton. In March 1870, after Levi Marsh indicated that he could no longer continue under the existing arrangements, Thomas Bent advised the trustees that Marsh was willing to remain on his former salary of £50 per annum if they erected a house in which he could live and care for the cemetery. It was further claimed that a large number of people were prepared to subscribe towards its construction. For decades the trustees acknowledged the need for a sexton’s residence but lacked the funds to build one. The issue had contributed to disputes with earlier sextons, including John Hooton jnr, who repeatedly pressed for improved conditions during his period of service. 4

Marsh later explained that the irregular demands of the office repeatedly cost him other employment. He was required to remain available for funerals, often at short notice, but the cemetery’s limited income prevented the trustees from offering sufficient full-time remuneration. His experience demonstrated how closely the proposed residence was connected with the wider question of securing the sexton’s continuous services. 5

The pressure continued under John Hooton. In January 1879 he complained that living at a distance prevented him from attending properly to the cemetery and repeatedly caused him to lose other employment. Unless his remuneration was increased or something was done towards “building the house according to promise”, he warned that he would have to relinquish the office. 6

Hooton did not live to see the trustees finally realise the long-promised project. After leaving the cemetery he was buried at Melbourne General Cemetery. He died in tragic circumstances on 5 June 1886 at only 40 years of age. His widow died the following month, leaving ten children. The family’s misfortunes continued, with both of Hooton’s parents dying within the following year and his sister-in-law the year after that. The sequence of losses serves as a poignant reminder of the personal hardships that often lay behind the cemetery’s administrative records. 7

Between 1868 and 1880 the proposal for a sexton’s cottage was raised on numerous occasions but never progressed to completion. The project was repeatedly delayed by more urgent expenditure on boundary fencing, uncertainty over government assistance, and the cemetery’s limited finances. Although trustees consistently agreed on the desirability of a residence, practical and financial obstacles prevented construction. In January 1878 a sub-committee was appointed to raise funds for the erection of a sexton’s residence, yet little progress followed. A year later the secretary reported that, owing to the continuing commercial depression, no action had been taken to raise the necessary subscriptions. The issue remained unresolved throughout the following decade. As late as 1886 the trustees informed the Secretary of Lands that, although a sexton’s residence was “greatly needed”, its construction could not be entertained owing to a lack of funds. The scheme was therefore postponed repeatedly until the cemetery’s financial position finally improved. 8

One of these renewed attempts occurred during the early 1870s. In February 1873 the trustees reported that they were anxious to erect a residence in the hope of securing the sexton’s “undivided services” for improving the grounds. They intended first to seek government assistance and then obtain sufficient private subscriptions to construct a building costing about £200. In July they again sought the intervention of Thomas Bent, explaining that they wished to learn what assistance the Government might provide before appealing to the public. No aid followed. In February 1874 the trustees reported that the contemplated residence had not been erected, and the Department of Public Works subsequently advised that its available vote could not be used for that purpose. 9

By the mid-1880s the trustees had begun making financial provision for the long-delayed residence. In February 1885 they reported that, no further work being urgently required on the grounds, £100 of the available balance would be placed at interest, “having in view the desirability of erecting as soon as possible a Sextons residence”. The sum subsequently appeared in the cemetery accounts as a fixed deposit. Yet this remained insufficient. In October 1886, the trustees acknowledged that the residence was “greatly needed”, but maintained that its erection still could not be entertained for want of funds. The lack of accommodation continued to affect routine administration. In June 1886 monumental masons were instructed to give more than one day’s notice before bringing work to the cemetery because the sexton did not reside upon the grounds and could not be relied upon to be present without prior arrangement. 10

The trustees’ renewed confidence was assisted by broader changes in Victoria’s economy. Throughout the 1880s, rapidly rising property values and speculative investment transformed Brighton and much of suburban Melbourne. Yet prosperity was not universal, and the collapse of speculative ventures left many individuals facing financial ruin. In September 1889 prominent Brighton solicitor Thomas Crisp, whose losses in land speculation were reported to have weighed heavily upon him, took his own life. Contemporary newspapers described the tragedy as one of the “lamentable results” of the land boom. His funeral was subsequently held at Brighton Cemetery, where a large gathering of relatives and acquaintances followed his remains to their final resting place. 11

In January 1889 they again resolved that £100 should be placed on fixed deposit for one year, this time expressly “with a view of erecting a Sexton’s Residence at as early a date as possible”. In January 1892 the trustees resolved that steps should be taken “without delay” to provide a caretaker’s lodge and instructed the architect Percy Oakden to meet them at the cemetery and advise on its construction. Oakden was one of Victoria’s leading architects, responsible for a wide range of churches, public buildings, banks, residences and commercial structures throughout Victoria and Tasmania. By 1892 he had established a substantial professional reputation, and his appointment reflected the importance the trustees attached to a project that had been delayed for decades. The connection between Oakden and Brighton Cemetery would ultimately become a personal one, for after his death in 1917 he was buried within the grounds he had helped shape. After nearly four decades of discussion, fundraising efforts and repeated postponements, the long-envisaged residence had finally moved from aspiration to active planning. 12

Oakden’s firm was already known in the immediate district. Only months earlier, Oakden, Addison and Kemp had designed the new Wesleyan Church in Mill Street, North Brighton, opened in November 1891. Charles Stone, chairman of the cemetery trust, was a longstanding Wesleyan leader who lived opposite the church and was associated with its congregation. The appointment therefore brought together a prominent local Methodist layman and an architect whose work had recently become a conspicuous feature of the neighbourhood.13

Before tenders were called, Oakden had accompanied the trustees to the cemetery on 30 January 1892 to inspect a number of potential sites. After careful consideration they selected a position on the same side as the existing cemetery buildings, but further from the entrance and closer to the carriage road. An alternative proposal by trustee John Stamp to place the building near the North Road gates was not supported. Oakden was instructed to prepare sketch plans for a caretaker’s residence incorporating a minister’s waiting room, indicating that provision was being made for clergy officiating at funerals. 14

The site selected for the new lodge was somewhat unusual by Victorian cemetery standards. Rather than being located immediately adjacent to the principal entrance, the trustees chose a position within the fenced cemetery grounds, north of the outer reserve area and near the existing cemetery buildings. The majority may have been influenced by the fact that the land adjoining the main road remained part of the undeveloped outer reserve. A lodge erected near the boundary would have stood some distance from the principal burial sections and existing tool shed, potentially limiting its effectiveness as a base for supervision and protection. To the south lay the natural watercourse that followed the line of present-day Sussex Road before ultimately draining towards Elster Creek. At the time the surrounding ground had not yet been fully developed for burials and later became Sections ZA and ZB in the Church of England portion, Section N in the Presbyterian area, and additional Roman Catholic, Presbyterian and Methodist burial sections on the east side and south of the undeveloped Hebrew ground. Situated on the cemetery flats, the locality was known to be poorly drained and prone to waterlogging after heavy rain. The decision is particularly interesting because many major Victorian cemeteries established during the 1850s, including Melbourne General, St Kilda and Boroondara, placed their keeper’s residences near the main entrance where they could supervise arrivals and departures. Brighton initially appeared to follow the same principle, but the later development of the outer reserve and the relocation of the principal entrance further south to North Road left the lodge in a less prominent position than had originally been envisaged. 15

The plans were presented to a special meeting on 11 February. Oakden advised that the building would ordinarily cost about £1,000, although he believed the depressed state of the building market might produce a lower tender. Concerned about expense, the trustees carefully examined the plans and directed the architect to prepare a cheaper alternative by omitting a rear bedroom and storeroom in brick construction and substituting a verandah together with a weatherboard storeroom and bathroom. Tenders were then invited for both the original and modified designs (plans “A” and “B”). 16

Figure 13.1. Advertisement seeking tenders for the proposed caretaker’s cottage, February 1892. Source: The Age.

The economic downturn that followed the collapse of the land boom also affected the building industry. Oakden’s expectation that the depressed market might produce favourable tenders was soon borne out. Public advertisements inviting tenders for the “Caretaker’s Cottage” appeared in February 1892. Oakden, Addison and Kemp called for tenders to close at 4 p.m. on Tuesday, 8 March, with plans and specifications available for inspection both at the architects’ Melbourne office and at the Bay Street office of cemetery secretary S. P. Simmonds in Brighton. Simmonds, a local house, land and insurance agent whose office stood at the corner of Bay and Asling Streets near North Brighton station, effectively provided the cemetery’s day-to-day administrative base. This arrangement reflected the combination of metropolitan architectural expertise and local management that characterised the project. The tenders were opened on 8 March 1892, revealing strong competition among Melbourne builders. Twenty-one submissions were received. For Plan A, tenders ranged from £669 submitted by James Head to £998 11s by Bennie and Oliver. The full list, sorted by Plan A (lowest to highest): 17

Tenderer Plan A Plan B
James Head £669 £599
Boxshall and Leonard £694 7s 9d £625 5s 6d
Grundy and Williams £695 £625
J. C. Semken £708 15s £675
James Germon £739 £679
Name omitted (71 Little Park Street East, South Melbourne) £740 £680
Hayball and Bros. £748 5s £697 10s
D. Hehir £796 £713
T. Freeman £821 16s £655 11s
Ezra Dunham £826 £769
C. Cowper £826 13s 4d £665 6s 8d
W. B. Bland £829 6s £754 10s
W. Bartlett £831 £781
Cleary and Hause £877 £812
G. Beasley £890 £810
John Yeates £893 £813
W. Crowle and Co. £912 12s 6d £837
T. H. W. Davidson £926 £841
N. McMahon £934 £775
Thomas Pickering £983 13s £894 3s
Bennie and Oliver £998 11s £909 11s

Alternative prices were also submitted for Plan B, ranging from £599 offered by James Head to £909 11s by Bennie and Oliver. After consideration the trustees elected to proceed with Plan A and accepted the tender of Boxshall and Leonard for £694 7s 9d. The successful contractors were local Brighton builders, carpenters and joiners operating from Church Street, Middle Brighton, where they advertised their services shortly before the cemetery tenders were called. The spread of tenders, from £669 to almost £1,000, demonstrates the degree of competition among Melbourne builders during the economic downturn of the early 1890s. The trustees also directed that the fixed deposits established towards the residence should not be renewed, but transferred to the current account as they matured to help meet the cost of construction. The chairman and secretary were authorised to execute the contract. 18

Construction proceeded during 1892. At the same time arrangements were made to provide a Yan Yean water service to the cemetery. The trustees authorised the installation of one-inch galvanised piping and obtained permission to connect to the main in Mill Street. Subsequent advice led to part of the run being increased to one and a quarter inches to ensure adequate pressure. The architect supervised these works alongside the lodge contract, creating a reticulated water supply for use at the cemetery and the new residence. 19

Progress payments were made to the contractors as work advanced. By April, the trustees had authorised an initial payment of £100 and established procedures for future instalments upon certification by the architect. The surrounding grounds also required alteration. Roads were realigned to accommodate the new building, trees were removed from the selected site, drainage issues were addressed and preparations were made for the enclosure of a yard attached to the residence. 20

By July 1892, the building was approaching completion. Attention turned to practical details. Trustees arranged fencing around the residence, modifications to the entrance fencing, and improvements to the surrounding grounds. Financial pressure nevertheless remained evident. To meet the final payments and associated works, discussions were held regarding the possibility of obtaining a bank overdraft, and the bank required the trustees to accept joint and several liability for its repayment. Even at this late stage expenditure remained tightly controlled, and the provision of a copper for the residence was deferred. The difficulties associated with the low-lying site also persisted after completion. In October 1893, the trustees ordered 200 feet of agricultural drainpipe for the planted ground north of the new building. 21

An inspection of the nearly completed building took place in August 1892. The lodge was more than a simple dwelling. In addition to the caretaker’s quarters it contained a minister’s room intended for the use of clergy officiating at funerals. Considerable attention was given to its fittings and appearance. The trustees debated whether a wardrobe or curtained recess should be installed for the storage of surplices and other clerical garments, ultimately favouring a simpler arrangement. Venetian blinds were ordered for the windows, furniture procured for the minister’s room, and provision made for an office table, chairs, soap tray and other conveniences. Even a drinking cup was supplied at the new water tap. By October the secretary reported that all authorised work had been completed, although the furniture intended for the minister’s room had yet to be purchased.

The building that survives today remains one of the cemetery’s most distinctive structures. Designed in the English Domestic Revival, or Queen Anne, manner, it incorporates steeply pitched slate roofs with terra cotta cresting, tall chimneys decorated with strapwork, decorative half-timbering and contrasting brickwork. A faceted corner bay opens onto a verandah supported by turned timber posts with lancet-shaped brackets, while the projecting wings incorporate window bays and half-timbered bargeboards. Black body bricks are relieved by red banding and a red plinth, together with white tuckpointing. The interior rooms are plastered and comparatively austere, while a later sympathetic brick wall encloses the rear yard. In addition to providing accommodation for the sexton, the building contained a vestry, cemetery office and meeting room for the trustees. A heritage assessment undertaken in 1995 described it as a picturesque and sophisticated example of its architectural style whose significance derives both from its design and its prominent position within one of Melbourne’s most important cemeteries. 22

The final arrangements demonstrate the purpose for which the residence had always been intended. In August 1892, the trustees resolved that the sexton might occupy the dwelling portion of the building for the nominal rent of one shilling per month. In return he was required to devote the whole of his time to the care of the cemetery without any increase in salary or additional fees. The arrangement reflected the same principle first articulated by the trustees in 1867: that a resident caretaker would provide constant supervision and protection for the cemetery. 23

More than half a century later, the Lodge remained both a working part of the cemetery and a family home. In 1949, when Cecil Gill relinquished the secretaryship, Charles Franklin King Walker and his family moved into the residence. His daughter Pamela Chappell (née Walker), then aged 13, later remembered cemetery life with considerable affection. “It never worried me living here at all,” she recalled. “In fact I have quite fond memories. I enjoyed it!” The family entertained friends there, while Pamela celebrated both her 19th and 21st birthdays at the Lodge. Friends were even invited to stay overnight. One, a penfriend from Sydney, stayed with the family during the 1956 Olympic Games and continued to remember the visit fondly. Pamela recalled that once inside the Lodge, with its private garden enclosed by the cemetery wall, “you forget it was a cemetery.”

Figure 13.2. The Lodge and its garden, viewed from the main entrance road. For generations the building served as both a family residence and the administrative centre of Brighton General Cemetery. Photograph: Pamela Chappell collection.

The Lodge was also inseparable from the daily operation of the cemetery. Chappell remembered the workmen gathering at the gate of the men’s yard each morning and afternoon, waiting for the bell outside the office to signal the beginning of work at 8 a.m. and the end of the day at 5 p.m. She herself sometimes rang the bell. The bell itself survives, fixed to the left of the office entrance, providing a tangible reminder of the working routines Chappell remembered. She also recalled her father preparing for meetings of the trustees, polishing the boardroom table and setting out blotting-paper pads, pens, ink and notepaper. What had been conceived in the 19th century as a residence from which the cemetery could be supervised had therefore developed into something broader: a home, office, meeting place and centre of everyday cemetery life. 24

After nearly four decades of petitions, fundraising campaigns and financial delays, Brighton Cemetery had finally obtained the caretaker’s lodge so long desired by successive boards of trustees. The completed building stood as a visible sign of the cemetery’s growing maturity and permanence, fulfilling an ambition first advanced when concerns over security and vandalism prompted trustees to argue that the sexton should reside upon the grounds. Yet the Lodge ultimately fulfilled more than the practical purpose imagined by those who had campaigned for its construction. For successive cemetery officers and their families it became both a workplace and a home, standing at the centre of Brighton Cemetery’s daily life for generations. 25

References:

  1. Brighton General Cemetery Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 13-17a and 42-43. ↩︎
  2. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 34a-40. ↩︎
  3. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 51a-52. ↩︎
  4. Brighton General Cemetery Letter Book “A”, p. 19. ↩︎
  5. Letter Book “A”, pp. 34-36. ↩︎
  6. Letter Book “A”, pp. 116-118. ↩︎
  7. The Age, 8 July 1886, pp. 1 and 8; 6 July 1888, p. 1; John Hooton (d.1886), Melbourne General Cemetery, Baptist Compartment D, Grave 159. ↩︎
  8. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 126a-127, 127a, 141a-142a and 146a. ↩︎
  9. Letter Book “A”, pp. 51, 53, 61 and 64-67. ↩︎
  10. Letter Book “A”, pp. 216-218. ↩︎
  11. The Caulfield and Elsternwick Leader, 21 September 1889, p. 5; Thomas Crisp (d.1889), Brighton General Cemetery, Church of England Section U, Grave 127. ↩︎
  12. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 141a-142a, 146a and 156-157; Letter Book “A”, pp. 199-200 and 225; Percy Oakden (d.1917), Brighton General Cemetery, Methodist Section K, Grave 25; “Percy Oakden (1845-1917)“, Brighton General Cemetery website, retrieved 26 September 2026. ↩︎
  13. The Caulfield and Elsternwick Leader, 7 November 1891, p. 5; 14 November 1891, p. 5; Brighton General Cemetery Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 157-159. ↩︎
  14. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 157-157a. ↩︎
  15. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 157-157a; Brighton General Cemetery plans and section maps. ↩︎
  16. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 157a-158. ↩︎
  17. The Age, 25 February 1892, p. 3; Oakleigh Leader, 27 February 1892, p. 4; Brighton Southern Cross, 22 August 1896, p. 4. ↩︎
  18. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 158a-159a; The Caulfield and Elsternwick Leader, 6 February 1892, p. 2; Contemporary advertisements show that Boxshall and Leonard were Brighton-based builders, carpenters, timber merchants and ironmongers operating from Church Street, Middle Brighton. By December 1892, the partnership was in an assigned estate and its stock and working plant were being sold by auction, although A. Leonard later resumed business independently from the same premises. ↩︎
  19. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 159-160a. ↩︎
  20. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 160-162. ↩︎
  21. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 162a-164 and 166-166a. ↩︎
  22. City of Glen Eira Heritage Management Plan 1996 (Ward). ↩︎
  23. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 162a-163. ↩︎
  24. Oral history interview with Pamela Chappell (née Walker), 7 May 1999, author’s collection. ↩︎
  25. Trustee Minutes Book “A”, pp. 13-17a, 34a-40, 51a-52, 108a-111a, 126a-127, 146a and 156-165. ↩︎