A common saying among motorists that, even on the darkest night, they knew when they had crossed into the City of Brighton by the smoothness of the roads.
— The Argus, 4 December 1924
An aerial photograph supplied by Melbourne Air Service in late 1921 or early 1922 shows how comparatively undeveloped the approaches to Brighton Cemetery remained at that time. North Road was still an unmade and muddy roadway, while the land surrounding the cemetery was only sparsely built upon. Opposite the cemetery on Hawthorn Road, the building that later became the café stood virtually alone, before the small commercial precinct serving cemetery visitors developed around it. No tramway had yet been laid along Hawthorn Road. Visitors therefore continued to depend upon walking, horse-drawn vehicles, trains to nearby stations and the emerging motor-bus services. The photograph captures the district shortly before these arrangements were transformed by the extension of the electric tramway along Hawthorn Road to North Road. 1

Looking at the aerial photograph of 1921-22, it is difficult to imagine that only about three years later electric trams would be travelling along Hawthorn Road past the cemetery. The largely undeveloped road and sparse surrounding settlement were soon overtaken by the rapid growth of the district and increasing demand for public transport. Brighton Cemetery itself was generating substantial traffic. The cemetery averaged more than 1,350 interments a year throughout the 1920s, accompanied by mourners and the continuing flow of families returning to visit graves, while by 1925 motor buses were reportedly carrying nearly 500 people to the cemetery each Sunday. The growth of the surrounding population and the demand for convenient access to one of Melbourne’s busiest cemeteries were therefore important factors in the transformation of Hawthorn Road. The arrival of the electric tram in 1925 dramatically changed an approach to the cemetery that, only a few years earlier, had retained a distinctly undeveloped appearance. 2
The condition of North Road had long complicated access to the cemetery. As the principal approach to Brighton Cemetery, improvements to the road were of particular importance to funeral traffic and visitors, yet its condition had been a recurring concern over the years. The unmade roadway visible in the 1921-22 aerial photograph was therefore not an isolated inconvenience, but part of a longer history of difficulty in providing satisfactory access to the cemetery. Hawthorn Road could be equally troublesome. A contemporary inspection in December 1924 described its worst section as beginning near Brighton Cemetery, where the roadway was riddled with deep “potholes”. Motorists were warned that only careful driving would avoid broken springs or other damage, while delivery carts reportedly avoided the made roadway altogether and used the softer side tracks. The deterioration was particularly striking because Brighton’s roads had once enjoyed an enviable reputation. The writer recalled that in 1912 it was “a common saying among motorists” that, even on the darkest night, they knew when they had crossed into the City of Brighton by the smoothness of the roads. “Today,” came the rather cutting conclusion, “the Brighton roads are among the worst in the metropolitan area.” The report called for the urgent reconstruction of Hawthorn Road and Point Nepean Road. 3
Brighton Cemetery had become a recognised destination within Melbourne’s developing transport network by the early 1920s. In March 1924 Caulfield Council approved a proposal by Trak Motor ’Bus Pty Ltd to establish a service between Brighton Cemetery and the city. The route was to operate through Kooyong Road, Clarence Street, Orrong Road, Dandenong Road, Wellington Street and St Kilda Road. Council authorised a bus stand on the western side of Kooyong Road, north of North Road, together with a separate stand for surplus buses on the opposite side of the road. The proposal demonstrates that the cemetery generated sufficient passenger traffic to be considered as the terminus of a direct service to central Melbourne and formed part of the broader expansion of suburban motor transport during the 1920s. 4
Travel to Brighton Cemetery by horse-drawn vehicle could itself involve hazards. On 23 September [year], a cab carrying eight passengers along Hawthorn Road to the cemetery collided with a pony and jinker. Twelve-year-old Marie Claringbold was thrown from the front of the cab, breaking an arm and fracturing a thigh. The driver of the jinker, William Conquest, was subsequently convicted of being drunk while in charge of a vehicle and of negligent driving. The incident provides a vivid example of the traffic already using Hawthorn Road to reach the cemetery before the arrival of the electric tramway. 5
Other funeral journeys encountered more mechanical difficulties, even after the improvement of Melbourne’s roads and transport services. In November 1924 a mourning coach carrying six passengers from Port Melbourne to Brighton Cemetery suffered a mechanical failure in Barkly Street, St Kilda, when one of its front wheels came off after running hot. The driver managed to bring the vehicle to a halt within a short distance and none of the occupants was injured. Although minor in itself, the incident provides a reminder that funeral processions remained dependent upon horse-drawn transport well into the 20th century and were still vulnerable to the kinds of mishaps that had accompanied road travel for generations. 6
For some families, reaching Brighton Cemetery involved a combination of transport. In 1999, Jan Montgomery recalled a story told to her by her father about the family’s regular visits following the death of his mother, Selina Florence Payne, in 1923. Each weekend, William Henry Payne and his five children travelled by train from their home in Hampton to Gardenvale station, then continued by horse and jinker to Brighton Cemetery to place flowers on Selina’s grave. The recollection provides a rare glimpse of the practical journey made by an ordinary family visiting the cemetery during the early 1920s, when railway travel could still be combined with horse-drawn transport for the final stage of the journey. 7
Alongside traditional funeral transport, motor buses were becoming increasingly important in bringing visitors to Brighton Cemetery. In January 1925 Trak Motors announced that its service from Ormond through Gardenvale to the beach would cease after the Motor Advisory authorities stipulated that the service should operate via North Road. The company regarded the altered route as unprofitable because it would no longer adequately serve passengers using Gardenvale railway station and the surrounding shopping area. The loss was particularly significant for Brighton Cemetery visitors. It was estimated that nearly 500 people were carried to the cemetery by Trak buses each Sunday, providing a striking indication of the volume of regular weekend visitation to the cemetery. 8
The large numbers travelling to Brighton Cemetery on weekends also supported businesses catering specifically to cemetery visitors. Oral recollections describe a café near the Hawthorn Road and Gardenvale Road corner which served people visiting the cemetery, with flowers sold from its verandah, particularly at weekends. The aerial photograph of late 1921 or early 1922 shows the building standing virtually alone opposite the cemetery, before other buildings developed around it. Sands and McDougall directories provide further evidence of the business and its changing proprietors. In 1925 Thomas D. Seach was listed as operating tea rooms at the Wawn Street corner, the street later renamed Gardenvale Road. By 1930 the tea rooms were operated by Mrs A. M. Steel, followed by A. Matthews in 1935, R. C. Mathews in 1940 and A. G. Tillett in 1950. Cemetery visits could form part of a regular family outing, with visitors travelling by public transport, purchasing flowers and proceeding to the cemetery, while others reportedly brought food and picnicked within the grounds. The recollections add a social dimension to the remarkable volume of Sunday traffic recorded during the 1920s. Visiting Brighton Cemetery was not necessarily a brief journey made only for a funeral, but could occupy a substantial part of the day. Together with the monumental masons established around the cemetery, the tea rooms illustrate the small commercial precinct that developed around the steady flow of mourners and grave visitors. 9
A major improvement in access to Brighton Cemetery came in early 1925 with the extension of the Hawthorn Road electric tramway from Glen Huntly Road to North Road. Following successful trial runs, regular services over the new section commenced on Sunday, 1 March 1925. The new service ran from Chapel Street, Prahran, via Dandenong Road and Hawthorn Road to North Road, passing Brighton Cemetery along the way. Contemporary reports described it as a great convenience both to residents around North Road and to visitors to the cemetery. Trams were scheduled at ten-minute intervals, while passengers could also travel by rail to Windsor or Elsternwick and continue by tram to Brighton Cemetery. Initial proposals contemplated services from Elsternwick and Glen Huntly railway stations branching into Hawthorn Road, although plans subsequently favoured a continuous service from North Road to Chapel Street, Windsor, via Dandenong Road. It was also anticipated that the eventual conversion of the St Kilda Road and Wellington Street cable tramways to electric traction would permit a continuous electric service between North Road and the city. The extension represented a significant improvement in public transport access to Brighton Cemetery and placed the cemetery directly upon Melbourne’s expanding electric tramway network. The arrival of the tram was also remembered as a local event. Robert W. Sinclair, then a schoolboy living near the cemetery, recalled running down from school to see the first trams arrive at Brighton Cemetery. For local children, the opening of the line was evidently more than a change to a timetable: it was a visible sign of the rapid transformation taking place around the cemetery during the 1920s. Further changes to the tramway network followed at the end of 1925. As part of the conversion of St Kilda’s cable tramways to electric traction, it was anticipated that the electrified Wellington Street line would enable Brighton Cemetery trams to continue beyond Chapel Street to the St Kilda Esplanade. The change promised to improve connections between the cemetery service and the developing electric tramway network, although the contemporary announcement made the arrangement conditional upon the Wellington Street line being ready in time. 10
Despite the improvement in tram access, difficulties associated with fares soon became apparent. In September 1925 a correspondent signing as “A.A.W.” complained that the Tramways Board would not issue transfer tickets for passengers travelling from the Glen Huntly Road route to Brighton Cemetery, although such tickets were available for journeys to the Balaclava Road junction. According to the writer, this meant that visitors from Glen Huntly and Elsternwick were required to pay the Sunday surcharge twice and were denied the benefit of a through fare. The complaint demonstrates that access to Brighton Cemetery was not simply a question of whether tram services existed, but also of how the separate routes, transfers and fare arrangements affected those travelling to the cemetery. 11
Dissatisfaction with the tram arrangements continued into the following year. In August 1926 the Elsternwick Traders’ Association, acting through Caulfield Council, submitted a petition signed by 423 residents seeking the rerouting of the Brighton Cemetery tram service along Glen Huntly Road to either Elwood or Elsternwick Railway Station. Supporters argued that the altered route would better serve local residents and visitors. The proposal was considered by the Tramways Board, but rejected later that month. Board officials concluded that the existing route along Hawthorn Road remained the most convenient arrangement for the travelling public. The Board also rejected requests for a reduced through fare between Brighton Cemetery and the city, arguing that passengers travelled over two separate tram routes rather than a single continuous service. Councillors strongly disputed the explanation and urged the Board to reconsider. Although unsuccessful, these campaigns demonstrate both the popularity of Brighton Cemetery and the extent to which funeral and visitor traffic had become an established feature of suburban transport planning. 12

Newspapers occasionally recorded dramatic incidents that happened in the vicinity of Brighton Cemetery. In March 1928 a motorcycle and sidecar carrying three people collided head-on with an electric tram just beyond the cemetery gates in Hawthorn Road, Caulfield. The tram had only recently departed the Brighton Cemetery terminus when the collision occurred at a section where the double tramway merged into a single track. The impact overturned the motorcycle and trapped the rider, John Gynn, 23, beneath the wreckage. Moments later the machine burst into flames and, despite rescue attempts by tramway staff and passers-by, Gynn was burnt to death. His passenger, Marguretta King, aged 24, later died from her injuries in the Alfred Hospital, while James Fraser survived with a compound fracture of the leg. Although unrelated to cemetery operations, the accident illustrates the increasing interaction between trams and motor vehicles on the roads surrounding the cemetery and provides a sobering reminder of the hazards of early motor transport. The danger was formally recognised the following year. In April 1929 an illuminated warning sign was erected in Hawthorn Road near Brighton Cemetery, where the double and single tram tracks converged and where fatal accidents had occurred. The sign had been requested by the South Caulfield and District Progress Association and was erected by the Tramways Board. Yet fatalities continued. In January 1932 Archibald Thomas McPhee, aged 31, was killed instantly when his motor cycle combination collided head-on with a tram outside Brighton Cemetery. McPhee was travelling on the correct side of Hawthorn Road, but the tram was approaching on the same side because the single track ran along the eastern side of the road. The continuing danger prompted renewed calls for the single tram line to be duplicated. At their annual meeting in February 1932, the trustees resolved to write to the Melbourne and Metropolitan Tramways Board drawing attention to the number of accidents that had occurred on the single-track section of tramway outside the cemetery and requesting that the double line be extended to North Road. The concern was shared beyond the cemetery trust. At the same time, the Caulfield Progress Association was preparing to discuss action to persuade the Tramways Board to complete the duplication of the line along the cemetery frontage. Citing fatal accidents in the locality, the association considered the work urgent, noting that returning trams were required to travel for a quarter of a mile on the wrong side of the road before reaching the double track. By November 1934 the Tramways Board advised Caulfield Council that provision would be made for a double-track terminus in Hawthorn Road near North Road. Contemporary reporting noted that motorists had repeatedly complained of the danger created by trams travelling in both directions over the existing single track. Caulfield Council welcomed the decision and resolved to thank the Board. The long-standing danger was finally removed when the Hawthorn Road tramway along the cemetery frontage was duplicated as part of the works associated with the 1937 extension of the line south from Brighton Cemetery to Point Nepean Road. 13
Funeral journeys could also be disrupted by failures of communication. Eighteen-year-old Lindsay Scarlett was among five people who died following a level-crossing collision at Traralgon on 23 October 1931. His burial took place at Brighton Cemetery the following day, after a service at his East Malvern home. Through an unexplained misunderstanding, however, numerous relatives and friends arrived at Brighton Cemetery on Sunday, one day after the funeral. Among them were members of the Yinnar Tent of the Independent Order of Rechabites. The incident illustrates the difficulties of communicating funeral arrangements among mourners scattered across Melbourne and regional Victoria. 14
Concerns regarding safety on Hawthorn Road persisted in the years following the 1928 accident. At their annual meeting in February 1932, the trustees resolved to write to the Melbourne and Metropolitan Tramways Board drawing attention to the number of accidents that had occurred on the single-track section of tramway outside the cemetery and requesting that the double line be extended to North Road. The concern was shared beyond the cemetery trust. At the same time, the Caulfield Progress Association was preparing to discuss action to persuade the Tramways Board to complete the duplication of the line along the cemetery frontage. Citing fatal accidents in the locality, the association considered the work urgent, noting that returning trams were required to travel for a quarter of a mile on the wrong side of the road before reaching the double track. The proposals demonstrate that the dangers associated with the single-track arrangement remained a matter of concern several years after the fatal collision of 1928 and had become an issue for both the cemetery trustees and the wider community. 15
Access to the cemetery remained a source of complaint for passengers. In January 1934 a correspondent signing as “Brighton Cemetery (Caulfield)” complained about the need to change trams at St Kilda Junction when travelling to the cemetery, describing it as “surely the coldest spot in Melbourne” as well as a dangerous crossing. The writer observed that many passengers travelled out of their way through Elsternwick simply to avoid the interchange and called for a through tram service between Brighton Cemetery and the city. 16
The growing importance of the Brighton Cemetery tram service was also reflected in operating schedules. In December 1935 the Melbourne and Metropolitan Tramways Board introduced an amended timetable under which trams on the Brighton Cemetery to St Kilda Beach route commenced running thirty minutes earlier on weekdays and forty minutes earlier on Sundays. The first weekday tram, which had previously departed the cemetery at 6.49 a.m., was rescheduled to leave at 6.19 a.m. The expanded timetable provides further evidence of the route’s place within Melbourne’s suburban transport network and of the regular service now available to travellers using Brighton Cemetery. 17
Motor-bus proposals also continued. In October 1936 Caulfield Council considered a proposed service between Heyington railway station and Brighton Cemetery, travelling through parts of Kooyong and Hawthorn roads. Supporters argued that the route would provide a useful public service and act as a feeder to existing rail and tram services. The application was referred to the council’s public works committee. The proposal demonstrates that, even after Brighton Cemetery had become firmly established on the tramway network, its importance as a destination continued to generate proposals for additional public transport connections. 18
The significance of the route was further demonstrated in 1937 when the Hawthorn Road tramway was extended south from Brighton Cemetery to Point Nepean Road. Although the extension added a further fare section to the line, the Tramways Board announced that the concession fare of sixpence to the city would be retained in order to encourage settlement in Melbourne’s expanding outer suburbs. The extension effectively transformed Brighton Cemetery from the terminus of the route into an intermediate stop upon a longer suburban service. 19
References:
- Aerial photograph of Brighton General Cemetery, supplied by Melbourne Air Service, late 1921 or early 1922, formerly displayed in the Trustees’ Meeting Room; contemporary descriptive notes made by the author while examining the original photograph, author’s collection; Brighton General Cemetery Trustee Minutes Book “B”, pp. 192-194. ↩︎
- Compiled from Brighton General Cemetery Burial Registers, 1920-1929. ↩︎
- The Argus, 4 December 1924, p. 15. ↩︎
- The Herald, 20 March 1924, p. 15. ↩︎
- The Age, 21 October 1922, p. 15. ↩︎
- The Herald, 20 November 1924, p. 1. ↩︎
- Letter from Jan Montgomery to the author, 29 July 1999, author’s collection. ↩︎
- The Argus, 30 January 1925, p. 12. ↩︎
- Interview with Robert W. Sinclair, 24 May 1999, and subsequent correspondence, author’s collection; Sands and McDougall’s Melbourne and Suburban Directory, 1925, pp. 268-269; 1930, pp. 222-223; 1935, Hawthorn Road; 1940, Hawthorn Road; 1950, Hawthorn Road. ↩︎
- The Argus, 25 February 1925, p. 19; The Herald, 25 February 1925, p. 5 and 7 December 1925, p. 5; The Argus, 2 March 1925, p. 12; Interview with Robert W. Sinclair, 24 May 1999, and subsequent correspondence, author’s collection. ↩︎
- The Age, 23 September 1925, p. 16. ↩︎
- The Herald, 4 August 1926, p. 21; The Age, 18 August 1926, p. 13; The Prahran Telegraph, 20 August 1926, p. 4. ↩︎
- The Sun News-Pictorial, 15 March 1928, p. 3; 1 April 1929, p. 9 and 16 January 1932, p. 2; The Age, 15 March 1928, p. 9 and 28 November 1934, p. 14; The Argus, 17 March 1928, p. 29 (photo) and 13 January 1937, p. 10; The Herald, 15 March 1928, p. 1. ↩︎
- Morwell Advertiser, 6 November 1931, p. 2 and 27 November 1931, p. 4; Lindsay Gordon Scarlett (d.1931), Brighton General Cemetery, Presbyterian Section J, Grave 11A. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “B”, p. 311; The Age, 4 February 1932, p. 8. ↩︎
- The Sun News-Pictorial, 15 January 1934, p. 6. ↩︎
- The Argus, 17 December 1935, p. 10. ↩︎
- The Age, 14 October 1936, p. 12. ↩︎
- The Argus, 25 November 1937, p. 3. ↩︎
