I cover up doctors’ mistakes!
— Ronald Charles Walker, Brighton General Cemetery
Mourners were not always left in peace while attending Brighton Cemetery. In 1921 the trustees complained to the Commission of Public Health about what they described as the “objectionable practice” of monumental masons’ representatives approaching bereaved relatives and attempting to secure orders for tombstones immediately after funerals. Although the Commission acknowledged the complaint, it advised that its powers did not extend to activities occurring outside cemetery grounds.
The problem had already attracted the attention of the monumental masonry trade. In June 1921 Ralph Abercrombie, secretary of the Master Masons’ Association, described an extraordinary attempt to identify firms engaged in cemetery touting. The Association employed two private detectives, one of whom dressed in widow’s weeds, who posed as mourners beside a fictitious grave and collected business cards and photographs from representatives seeking orders for memorials. Abercrombie claimed that the practice was particularly prevalent at Brighton, Coburg and St Kilda, and that on Sunday afternoons Brighton Cemetery could be “literally swarming with touts”. When cemetery officials approached, he said, the representatives scattered, with some even scaling the fence. The investigation demonstrated the lengths to which the masonry trade itself was prepared to go in attempting to suppress a practice regarded as both intrusive to mourners and unfair to firms that refused to employ touts. 1
The concern soon produced a more explicit regulatory response. A regulation made under the Cemeteries Act in May 1921 prohibited any person from promoting or carrying on a trade or business within a cemetery by advertising, solicitation, distributing circulars or cards, or any other means. Breaches carried a penalty of up to £5. The regulation established a clear distinction between commercial approaches made within cemetery grounds and activities outside the boundary, where the health authorities had earlier acknowledged that their powers were more limited. 2
Similar concerns arose the following year when a proposal to permit the sale of flowers within the cemetery on Sundays attracted public opposition. A correspondent argued that Sunday trading should not be extended beyond essential services and urged that permission be refused. By 1923 another correspondent was complaining that “loafers and cadgers” regularly congregated around the cemetery gates and annoyed mourners attending funerals and graves. Similar allegations resurfaced in September 1923 when the Masons’ Association of Victoria reported that soliciting was being practised within Brighton Cemetery, “particularly on Sundays”, and asked the Public Health Department to investigate the matter under the Cemeteries Act 1915. The Department referred the complaint to Alexander Nicholson, Chief Commissioner of Police, requesting an investigation by a member of the Plain Clothes Police Force to determine whether the cemetery regulations had been infringed. The complaint passed through Brighton and Caulfield police before being referred for investigation. The allegation, however, was not substantiated. On 2 November the Public Health Department advised the Association that the matter had been investigated and that “no evidence can be obtained that soliciting for trade is being practised in or about Brighton Cemetery.” 3
The episode adds an important qualification to contemporary complaints about commercial activity around the cemetery. Solicitation was sufficiently concerning to prompt complaints from both the trustees and the monumental masonry trade, and in 1923 to warrant a police investigation, but on that occasion investigators could find no evidence that the alleged practice was actually occurring. The complaints nevertheless continued. In May 1926 a correspondent signing as “Fair Play” wrote that monumental masons were frequenting Brighton Cemetery on Saturday afternoons and Sundays to solicit work from visitors. The writer objected not only to the commercial approaches but to the manner in which representatives competed to reach prospective customers: “It is nothing for them to jump over graves to reach you first.” The complaint provides contemporary evidence that, whatever investigators had been able to establish in 1923, visitors were still reporting solicitation within the cemetery three years later. 4
Problems concerning graves were by no means confined to commercial solicitation. Cemetery officials were occasionally required to resolve disputes over burial rights themselves. In August 1879 a funeral at Brighton Cemetery descended into confusion after a coffin had already been lowered into a grave before relatives realised that the deceased was about to be buried in a public grave rather than in a privately owned family allotment. According to newspaper reports, objections were raised at the graveside, the coffin was lifted back to the surface and cemetery officials were summoned to investigate. The dispute continued for so long that the burial could not be completed before the cemetery closed, with the newspaper reporting that “the body [was] to remain unburied until the following day.” The episode provides a rare glimpse of the practical and emotional difficulties that could arise when ownership, family expectations and burial arrangements came into conflict. 5
Questions surrounding the ownership and resale of graves surfaced again many years later. In March 1933 the Brighton trustees were asked to comment upon allegations of “trafficking in graves” in public cemeteries. The complaint alleged that undertakers were purchasing graves for resale, in some cases using fictitious names and addresses, and retaining certificates of right of burial rather than passing them to the purchasers. Possession of the certificate could then enable a grave to be resold without the knowledge of the Cemetery Trust, with any profit incorporated into the general cost of the funeral. The correspondence did not establish that the alleged practice was occurring at Brighton, but it exposed a potential weakness in a system under which certificates representing burial rights commonly remained in the possession of funeral directors rather than the people for whom the graves had been purchased. 6
Cemetery records and trustee minutes often focus upon administration and burial activity, yet newspaper reports occasionally provide glimpses of the experiences of ordinary visitors. In April 1923 a six-year-old girl visiting Brighton Cemetery with her parents accidentally fell into a newly dug grave. The child’s father immediately entered the grave and lifted the child to safety with assistance from a nearby bystander. Fortunately, the girl escaped injury apart from fright. Local residents used the incident to argue that open graves should be better protected, particularly where narrow paths brought visitors close to freshly excavated burial sites. 7
Visitors occasionally found that the cemetery exposed them to risks other than uneven ground and open graves. In October 1923 Elizabeth B. Goslett of Wattletree Road, Malvern, reported that while visiting the grave of her father, Charles Goslett, at Brighton Cemetery she briefly left her personal belongings nearby, only to discover on her return that they had been stolen. Newspaper reports described the loss as including a cape, handbag, money and other personal effects, with the total value estimated at more than £100. The incident was widely reported as a particularly callous theft because it occurred while a visitor was attending the grave of a family member. 8
In May 1924 another cemetery visit ended in very different circumstances. Annie Willett, aged 42, of Derby Road, Caulfield, was about to enter Melbourne General Cemetery when she suddenly collapsed at the corner of Wilson and Macpherson streets and died before medical assistance could be obtained. The following day Willett was herself buried at Brighton General Cemetery. The melancholy coincidence provides one of the more unusual connections between Brighton Cemetery and another of Melbourne’s burial grounds. 9
Visitors occasionally found that their concerns extended beyond the cemetery grounds themselves. In November 1930 the motor car of H. G. Taylor of East Malvern was stolen while its owner attended a funeral at Brighton Cemetery. The vehicle was later recovered at Bendigo, where police discovered three young men and two female companions travelling in it. One of the accused, Charles Sloan, admitted responsibility and was sentenced to twelve months’ imprisonment, while two co-accused were discharged after being found not guilty. The incident illustrates the vulnerability of mourners whose attention was naturally directed towards funeral proceedings rather than the security of vehicles left outside the cemetery. 10
The cemetery also occasionally became part of the story when severe weather affected the surrounding district. On 29 December 1950 a sudden thunderstorm caused flooding across Melbourne and its suburbs. Along Hawthorn Road at East Brighton, floodwater collected beside Brighton Cemetery, where children were photographed paddling and playing in the water while vehicles made their way through the flooded roadway. The photograph, taken by F. Frueh of Pascoe Vale and subsequently published in The Argus, provides an unusual view of the cemetery boundary and Hawthorn Road during a suburban flood. 11

The cemetery wall itself became involved in another police incident in August 1955. A police patrol travelling along Hawthorn Road was responding to a report that three men were attempting to steal a car in North Road, Ormond, when a hire car turned from Gardenvale Road. The patrol driver braked and swerved, clipping the other vehicle before the police car crashed head-on into the Brighton Cemetery wall. Constable Gordon Hunter fell from the patrol car as it rebounded and was caught between the vehicle and the gutter, being dragged for about ten yards. The driver, Constable Frank Lee, struck his head on the dashboard and collapsed after leaving the vehicle. Both were taken to the Alfred Hospital and treated for cuts and shock, while the badly damaged patrol car had to be towed away. The episode added an unusual motor-vehicle collision to the long list of incidents in which the cemetery and its boundary became unexpectedly involved in events occurring in the surrounding suburb. For a wall that had so often refused to stand straight, it could still prove a formidable line of defence. 12
In September 1885 an inquest was held into the death of an unidentified infant whose body had been found in scrub near “Caulfield” Cemetery [sic] by Samuel Armstrong and Eden Waghorn. Medical evidence attributed the death principally to starvation, accelerated by exposure and neglect, and a verdict of wilful murder was returned against an unknown person or persons. The case did not end with the inquest. The Government subsequently offered a reward of £50 for information leading to the arrest of the person responsible. The incident provides a grim reminder of the very different character of the district when undeveloped scrub still surrounded parts of the cemetery. 13
The cemetery reserve and surrounding open ground occasionally attracted activities that had nothing to do with funerals or remembrance. On 18 October 1925 police raided a game of two-up being played near Brighton Cemetery. The raiding party arrived in two motor cars and a van carrying police recruits, while scouts watched the gathering and signalled when officers should surround the players. Several participants escaped over the cemetery walls and sought refuge among the tombstones, but all were eventually apprehended. Twenty-four young men subsequently appeared before Brighton Court, where each was fined £2, with fourteen days’ imprisonment in default, for playing two-up and being deemed a rogue and vagabond. The incident provides a curious example of the cemetery being drawn into the recreational and policing history of the surrounding district, its walls and monuments briefly serving as cover for men attempting to escape an illegal gambling raid. 14
The cemetery occasionally attracted attention for reasons quite unrelated to funerals or administration. In February 1930 two men, George Smith, aged 60, and William Joseph Toohey, aged 55, appeared before the Caulfield Court after being arrested near Brighton Cemetery. Plain-clothes Constable Michael John James Murphy told the court that the men had been drinking methylated spirits and were “bordering on ‘the horrors'”, with Toohey found crawling about in the grass. Murphy described them as a nuisance to the district and said that women were afraid to leave their homes because of them. Smith told the court that he had camped near Brighton Cemetery “for about 20 years off and on”. The pair, who between them admitted or were attributed 89 previous convictions, were each sentenced to six months’ imprisonment. Mr Bond remarked that a few months in gaol would “get the drink out of their systems”. 15
Visitors did not always agree with the way Brighton Cemetery was managed. In June 1929 a regular visitor writing under the pseudonym “Long Wait” complained to The Herald after arriving at 9.45 a.m. to find the cemetery gates secured with a padlock and chain. Having visited the cemetery in the early morning for many years, the correspondent objected to a newly enforced rule that delayed opening until 10 a.m. The writer argued that many people wished to visit graves before going out for the day and expressed the hope that the restriction would soon be amended. The complaint provides a glimpse into the routines of cemetery visitors and demonstrates how strongly some members of the public felt about access to the graves of family members. The locking of cemetery entrances was not itself new: as early as 1899 the trustees had ordered the northern gate in the Independent portion to be secured after dark and the small gate at the principal entrance to be locked before the sexton retired for the night. 16
The cemetery’s newly planted grounds also attracted less conspicuous intruders. In October 1900 the secretary reported that rabbits had damaged the new shrubs in the reserve. Wire netting was placed around the plants for protection, while the sexton was instructed to take steps to have the rabbits destroyed. The incident offers a small reminder that the cemetery still lay on Melbourne’s suburban fringe, where ornamental improvements had to contend with grazing cattle and destructive wildlife. 17
Damage to private memorial work could also leave the trustees in an awkward position. In July 1901 the secretary reported that he had authorised the repair of a grave fence belonging to Mr Payton because he could not determine whose workmen had caused the damage. The trustees agreed to pay the £1 account, but firmly directed that no similar order should be given again, since the Trust could not be held responsible for damage caused by anyone other than its own employees. The decision exposed a recurring difficulty in a cemetery where monumental masons, contractors and other workmen regularly operated among privately owned graves and memorials. 18
Not all complaints concerned burials or cemetery operations. In December 1927 a correspondent to The Age expressed outrage after discovering election posters promoting a reform ticket for the St Kilda Football Club pasted on the walls of Brighton Cemetery. Describing the practice as a desecration of sacred ground, the writer called upon the trustees to identify those responsible and take action. Whether the offenders were ever found is unknown, but the complaint illustrates the strong public expectation that the cemetery should remain a place of dignity, free from advertising and other intrusions of everyday suburban life. 19
Young offenders periodically caused less extensive damage than the wholesale vandalism of 1949. In February 1940 the trustees ordered memorial stones damaged by vandals to be repaired free of charge, although they expressly stated that the decision was not to create a precedent. Later that year a boy was caught damaging ornaments upon a grave. His mother agreed to pay 15s for a broken glass shade, and the trustees decided that no further action would be taken once the boy’s parents had made good the loss. In November 1944 another outbreak occurred when several memorial stones were “wantonly damaged” and articles upon graves disturbed during the night. The matter was reported to police, but no result had been received by the time of the trustees’ meeting. These smaller incidents show that the destruction uncovered in 1949 was not without precedent. 20
The most serious outbreak of vandalism occurred during March and April 1949, when three 15-year-old Caulfield schoolboys were questioned by police following extensive damage within Brighton Cemetery. The attacks occurred on 21 and 24 March and 9 April. After 23 graves were damaged during the first incident, detectives visited the cemetery several times. The damage included uprooted steel grave-number discs and smashed glass domes, marble books, headstones and jardinières. On 9 April two cemetery masons heard stone being broken and caught two boys near the gates; a third boy was subsequently questioned at home. The damage was initially estimated at £400, and police announced that the three boys would be summoned before the Children’s Court for malicious damage. Police noted that many of the damaged memorials were already irreplaceable. Subsequent investigations by the trustees identified 36 damaged graves. 21
The settlement of the 1949 vandalism case was almost as unusual as the damage itself. The fathers of the boys offered compensation if their sons were not prosecuted, eventually increasing the proposed payment from £300 to £400. The trustees obtained legal advice about whether such an arrangement was permissible and ultimately accepted the £400, informing police that they did not desire a prosecution. Reparation forms were sent to the owners of 36 damaged graves, although only 15 letters could be delivered and 11 replies were received. Repairs cost £253 12s 11d, including marble figures imported from Italy, and the unused balance of £146 7s 1d was later returned to the parents. The boys nevertheless appeared before the Children’s Court in relation to a later incident: two were placed on probation for twelve months, while the third was returned to the care of the Children’s Welfare Department. 22
Vandalism continued to trouble the cemetery after the war. In January 1968, following what Secretary Frank Norman Allen described as an apparent outbreak of vandalism, cemetery officials inspected the grounds with Caulfield Police to determine how intruders were entering outside the prescribed opening hours. Attention centred upon two trees growing in Sheffield Street beside the cemetery boundary, one of which was being used as a convenient stepping point to scale the high brick wall. The Trust and police wanted the trees removed, regarding their proximity to the wall as providing vandals with a ready means of access. Allen therefore asked Caulfield City Council to have them removed “at the very first opportunity”.
Caulfield City Council was unconvinced. The Council refused the request, arguing that removal of the trees would not prevent vandals from entering the cemetery and suggesting instead that wire be placed along the top of the wall. The Trust continued to press for removal of the trees, but in March the Council reaffirmed its refusal. The dispute was another manifestation of the sometimes combative relationship between the two bodies. The Cemetery Trust regarded the trees immediately outside its boundary as facilitating unauthorised access, while the Council preferred altering the cemetery wall itself rather than removing the trees from Sheffield Street. 23

The trustees were sometimes more cautious about exhumations than the health authorities considered necessary. In August 1920 the Law Department questioned Brighton’s practice of refusing to permit the removal of remains until they had been buried for twelve months. The Department pointed out that the Board of Public Health had concluded as early as 1910 that no public-health benefit was gained by imposing such a delay in ordinary non-infectious cases. The Government Medical Officer had similarly advised that, under skilled supervision and with suitable disinfection, an exhumation could be performed without risk at any period after interment. The Minister therefore suggested that the trustees reconsider their twelve-month restriction. The principle was demonstrated in 1925 when permission was granted to remove the remains of Mary Campbell Fleming from Brighton Cemetery to the Eastern Cemetery at Geelong. Health authorities advised that even recently buried remains could be transferred safely provided that the coffin was thoroughly disinfected and enclosed within a hermetically sealed shell, and the Solicitor-General consequently issued a licence for the removal. 24
Another proposed exhumation raised quite different concerns. In March 1927 an application was made to disturb the remains of Norman Frusher, aged 15, at Brighton Cemetery for the purpose of deepening the grave. Frusher, who had died on 14 February 1925, was recorded as having died from tetanus. The cemetery secretary reported that the local Health Officer opposed the request because the tetanus organism lived in the soil and considered that the grave diggers would be exposed to risk in handling the remains. There was also a complication over burial rights: the secretary pointed out that the Certificate of Right of Burial was not held in the name of the applicant, Mrs Lillian Frusher. When the matter was referred through the Crown Law Department, the Commission of Public Health supported the Medical Officer of Health’s opinion and refused approval. The burial register contains no subsequent notation indicating that Frusher’s remains were removed or re-interred. The incident illustrates that requests to disturb an existing burial could involve considerations extending beyond family wishes and rights of burial to the safety of the cemetery employees expected to carry out the work. 25
Errors involving grave ownership could produce more serious difficulties. Francis Griffin already owned grave 96 in Roman Catholic Section R when, in 1921, he purchased the adjoining grave 97 for the purpose of keeping deceased members of his family together. A title was issued to him, but only two weeks later Mary Butler was buried in grave 97 and a separate title was issued to her husband, Edward. Butler was subsequently buried in the same grave on 20 February 1933. When the mistake was discovered, the secretary wrote to Griffin on 1 July 1935, informed him that both Mary and Edward Butler had been interred in grave 97, and asked him to accept another grave in its place. Griffin did not initially reply, and in August 1935 the trustees instructed the secretary to write again and invite him to call and settle the matter. The trustees offered Griffin grave 45, the only other grave then available in the same compartment, but he refused to accept another grave and asked that the bodies mistakenly interred in grave 97 be removed. The trustees declined and instead reserved grave 45 for him. The surviving papers record no resolution of the dispute, and there is no indication that Griffin ever took up the substitute grave; grave 45 was subsequently used for other burials. Grave 97 remained undisturbed, with Mary and Edward Butler still interred there. What had been lost was therefore not simply another burial plot, but the adjoining family grave Griffin had deliberately purchased. The long-running dispute demonstrates the distress and administrative difficulty that could follow when a grave was sold twice and the error was discovered only after interments had taken place. 26
Another extraordinary burial mix-up occurred in November 1974 when the funeral of Amy Hall arrived at Brighton Cemetery and staff discovered that no grave had been reserved or prepared. A tentative booking had been made with the cemetery superintendent, but the funeral director had not subsequently confirmed it. With another funeral due at 4 p.m. and the grave for that burial already prepared, the superintendent faced an immediate predicament. Rather than tell Hall’s relatives that no grave was ready, her casket was committed to the grave prepared for the later funeral. No soil was placed over it, and after the mourners had departed the casket was removed from the grave and returned to the funeral parlour. The 4 p.m. burial then proceeded in the grave as originally intended.
A new grave immediately beside it was subsequently prepared, although hard ground and the need to dig other graves delayed its completion. On 11 November Hall’s casket was returned to Brighton Cemetery and interred in the new grave. When the incident came to the attention of the Truth newspaper and the Commission of Public Health, Chairman Ian Lovell acknowledged that “the greatest wrong” was that Hall’s relatives had not been told at the time that the correct arrangements had not been made, although he maintained that the decision had been taken “by the highest of motives – not to cause them further anguish”. On behalf of the trustees he expressed his “profound regret over the incident”. The matter did not entirely end there. In February 1975 the trustees considered an approach from Miss Hall and resolved, despite the Chairman’s recorded disagreement, that “no Action be taken” over the burial. They nevertheless drew a clear lesson from what had occurred, directing that if similar circumstances arose in future, the family must be informed of the situation and of any action proposed to overcome it. The Hall correspondence was retained by the Chairman and was to be circulated among the trustees. 27
Family disputes occasionally spilled into the cemetery itself. In October 1936 proceedings before the County Court arose from an alleged slander said to have taken place during a visit to Brighton Cemetery. The plaintiff, George Sneezum, claimed damages from his wife’s brother and sister-in-law after remarks were allegedly made while members of the family visited the grave of his father-in-law. Evidence presented to the court suggested that the dispute centred upon money, employment and accusations concerning the plaintiff’s character. The defendants denied making the statements complained of and argued that, if any remarks had been made, they were spoken on a privileged occasion. The case serves as a reminder that cemeteries were not merely places of burial and remembrance, but also settings in which existing family tensions sometimes surfaced. 28
An unusual coincidence of death brought a husband and wife to Brighton Cemetery together in July 1953. Charles Newby Butt, a retired butcher of Rusden Street, Elsternwick, died at the age of 74 on 13 July. His wife, Mary Ellen Butt, also aged 74, had awakened to find him dead and herself died later that day. A memorial service was arranged at the Methodist Church in Orrong Road, Elsternwick, followed by private interment at Brighton Cemetery. The cemetery records confirm that Charles and Mary were interred together on 15 July in Baptist Section L, Grave 69D. Their headstone records the remarkable coincidence simply: both “passed away 13th July 1953”, both aged 74 years. 29
A similarly complicated dispute arose in February 1938 when Mrs E. Lincoln complained that she had not been told that another person was already buried in a public grave containing the remains of her first husband. After converting the grave into a private grave and later burying her second husband there, she discovered that no further space remained, although she believed that her deed allowed three interments. Mrs Lincoln asked that the earlier remains be exhumed so that she might eventually be buried in the grave herself. The secretary rejected her interpretation, explaining that she had paid for only two interments and had not been deprived of any right recorded in the deed. Three months later the trustees permitted her to purchase another grave, into which she proposed eventually to transfer her husband’s remains when she could afford the expense. 30
The trustees also became participants in what developed into an annual social tradition among funeral and cemetery workers. In November 1915 the Undertakers’ Association and General Employees’ Union asked that cemetery employees be granted leave to attend its annual picnic, but the request was refused. Four years later the response was markedly different. After the Undertakers’ Employees Association asked that the cemetery be closed for burials on 19 November 1919, the employees’ annual holiday, and requested a donation towards the picnic prizes, the trustees agreed to close the cemetery after 10.30 a.m. and contribute one guinea to the picnic fund. Similar requests were thereafter granted with striking regularity. During the early 1920s the cemetery was commonly closed to funerals after 10 or 10.30 a.m., while in later years the trustees allowed as many employees as possible to attend and continued the customary donation of £1 1s. By 1936 the arrangement had become sufficiently established for the trustees simply to grant the employees a holiday and donate one guinea to the picnic fund. The following year the Cemetery Employees’ Wages Board formally recognised the third Wednesday in February as Union Picnic Day, providing that employees should, as far as practicable, receive the day as a holiday without deduction of pay. Later that year, the revised wages determination expressly included the employees’ picnic day among the holidays to which cemetery workers were entitled. Thereafter the guinea donation continued with remarkable regularity. It was still being paid in the late 1950s, when the annual gathering was held at Mordialloc, and in 1958 the union described the occasion as its 46th annual picnic. What might appear curious to a modern reader was evidently treated as an established obligation: each year the union sought not only the release of cemetery employees for its picnic, but also a financial contribution from the Trust towards the occasion. Far from regarding the request as inappropriate, the trustees came to recognise both the holiday and the guinea donation as part of the annual routine. 31
Complaints did not always come from mourners or grave owners. Relations between cemetery employees and funeral directors could also become strained. In November 1947 the Undertakers’ Assistants and Cemetery Employees’ Union complained that some undertakers ignored an agreement governing the times at which funerals should arrive. Cemetery employees were then placed in the awkward position of either refusing to work outside the agreed hours or assisting with the funeral and risking a union fine. The union asked the trustees to prohibit funerals between noon and 1 p.m. and after 4.15 p.m. The dispute provides an unusual glimpse of the practical tensions behind funeral arrangements, where a delayed cortege could bring cemetery employees, undertakers and union rules into direct conflict. 32
The ageing cemetery landscape occasionally created complaints quite independently of the conduct of its staff. In October 1998 a large limb fell from a cypress tree in Church of England Section ZD, damaging several monuments. The Trust advertised in an attempt to locate the families concerned, but the incident later developed into a dispute over responsibility for the damaged Geach family memorial. In 1999 Ted Gillies obtained a quotation of $1,865 for its repair and sought assistance from the Trust. The cemetery’s insurer maintained that the Trust had taken reasonable precautions in its management of the trees and was not negligent, leaving the cost of repairs with the grave owner. The trustees nevertheless adopted a more conciliatory approach. Without accepting liability or establishing a precedent for similar claims, they agreed to contribute half the cost of repairing the monument. 33
On 9 June 2004 Brighton Cemetery became the setting for an extraordinary episode connected with Melbourne’s gangland conflicts. Sean Sonnet and Gregg Hildebrandt went to the Brighton Cemetery area as part of a conspiracy to murder underworld figure Mario Condello, who was known to walk his dog in the area each morning. Sonnet was carrying a loaded revolver and an automatic pistol, but Condello was not there that morning. Police, who had been monitoring the pair, intervened before the planned shooting could take place. Contemporary reports placed the arrests beside the Brighton Cemetery wall in North Road, near Condello’s home. At Sonnet’s original trial, the prosecution case was that Carl Williams had arranged the plot in revenge for the killing of Andrew Veniamin, and Sonnet was convicted in 2007 of conspiracy to murder Condello. Subsequent legal proceedings altered the evidentiary position and, by 2012, Condello could no longer be identified as the intended victim on the admissible evidence. Sonnet was ultimately sentenced to ten and a half years’ imprisonment for conspiring to murder a “person unknown”. The extraordinary episode placed Brighton Cemetery, for reasons entirely removed from its normal purpose, within the wider history of Melbourne’s gangland conflicts. 34
Visitors continued to make claims when accidents occurred within the grounds. In 1954 Mrs A. Porteous reported that she had tripped over a barrow and tools while visiting her mother’s grave, spraining both ankles and bruising her hip. She stated that she had been confined to bed for approximately three weeks. The trustees settled the matter with a payment of £15, expressly made without admission of liability. Four years later C. J. Herbert made another claim after falling during a visit to the cemetery, leading the trustees’ public-risk insurer to appoint an investigator. Such cases explain why the trustees had taken out public-liability insurance in 1938 after being warned that defective paths, equipment or employee negligence might expose the Trust to claims. 35
Public liability again became an issue following an accident at the cemetery office in April 1983. Edward Martin Robert Hunkin fell while leaving the office, sustaining a serious injury to his left ankle. County Court proceedings subsequently alleged that the trustees had failed to provide a safe means of access, drawing particular attention to the construction of the steps, the absence of a handrail and the alleged difficulty of distinguishing one of the steps from the surrounding surface. Damages of $100,000 were sought. Statements prepared in response presented a different view. Secretary-Manager Brian Gales described the entrance as having three bluestone steps with a red-brick step at the bottom and stated that he used them twenty or thirty times each day without having regarded them as unsafe. Foreman Noel Chrimes similarly recalled the steps as clean and said that he knew of no previous instance of anyone slipping on them.
The resulting proceedings also produced an unusual administrative complication. Gales wrote to the cemetery’s public-risk insurer after Brighton City councillors were included among the defendants, pointing out that they had “nothing to do with the Brighton Cemetery”. Although bearing Brighton’s name, the cemetery stood within the City of Caulfield and was administered by its own Cemetery Trust. Trustee Geoffrey Doolan also corresponded with the insurer after being named as a defendant, seeking confirmation that the insurer’s solicitors would represent the trustees. The episode therefore involved not only a claim arising from conditions within the cemetery but some confusion over where responsibility for the institution itself actually lay. 36
Newspapers did not always get every detail right. One report told the seemingly touching story of Frank Thomas Normoyle, who had been discharged after an inquiry into the death of a man identified as Ernest Drayton Thrower. Normoyle reportedly announced that he intended to visit Thrower’s grave at Brighton Cemetery and lay flowers there, explaining, “He was my best friend.” It was a poignant story, if only the details could be confirmed. No Ernest Drayton Thrower appears in the Brighton General Cemetery burial register, including among the interments immediately following his reported death on 17 November 1955, and no corresponding Victorian death registration has been located under that name. Whether the newspaper misstated the cemetery, the deceased’s name, or some other detail remains uncertain. 37
Brighton Cemetery acquired an unusual connection with the early development of television in Melbourne. During transmission testing from Mount Dandenong, engineers reportedly found that the area around the cemetery provided particularly good “ghost-free” reception. In television terminology, “ghosts” were multiple images caused by reflected signals. The cemetery area benefited from line-of-sight transmission from Mount Dandenong and, at the time, relatively few tall buildings capable of reflecting the signal. The description of Brighton Cemetery as a “ghost-free zone” provided an appropriately incongruous distinction for a burial ground. 38
Not every curious story associated with Brighton Cemetery found its way into the official records. According to Pamela Chappell (née Walker), her brother Ronald Charles Walker, who followed their father Charles into the cemetery administration, developed a rather ingenious way of describing his occupation. He is said to have used the line socially at parties, particularly when making the acquaintance of young women, as announcing that he worked at a cemetery might not have seemed the most promising beginning to a potential relationship – let alone marriage. When asked what he did for a living, Walker had a suitably evasive answer: “I cover up doctors’ mistakes!” 39
The joke neatly captured the particular black humour available to somebody whose working life revolved around a cemetery. It also provided Walker with an answer that was funny precisely because, in the most literal sense, there was an element of truth in it.
Taken together, these incidents show how difficult it was to preserve the cemetery as a place of dignity and quiet remembrance. Its walls could not entirely exclude theft, gambling, vandalism, family conflict or the ordinary hazards of suburban life. As public expectations changed, the trustees were required to do more than provide a burial ground: they were increasingly expected to protect visitors, safeguard private memorials, resolve disputes and accept responsibility when conditions within the cemetery caused loss or injury.
References:
- The Herald, 11 June 1921, p. 10. ↩︎
- Commission of Public Health, “Regulation for the Prevention of Advertising in Cemeteries”, made under the Cemeteries Act 1915, 27 May 1921; copy forwarded to Brighton General Cemetery, 26 July 1921. ↩︎
- The Argus, 2 February 1921, p. 10; The Herald, 11 September 1922, p. 8; The Argus, 29 August 1923, p. 21; Department of Health and Community Services file “Brighton Cemetery” (93/387/18 73), Part I (1900-1949), J. Fraser, Secretary, Masons’ Association of Victoria, to Secretary, Department of Public Health, 17 September 1923; Secretary, Public Health Department, to Chief Commissioner of Police, 20 September 1923; Secretary, Public Health Department, to J. D. Fraser, Secretary, Masons’ Association of Victoria, 2 November 1923. ↩︎
- The Sun News-Pictorial, 20 May 1926, p. 6. ↩︎
- The Brighton Southern Cross, 23 August 1879, [page unknown]. ↩︎
- Department of Health file relating to Brighton General Cemetery, Acting Secretary to Secretary, Brighton Cemetery Trust, 28 March 1933, correspondence concerning alleged “trafficking in graves” in public cemeteries. ↩︎
- The Herald, 2 April 1923, p. 9. ↩︎
- The Age, 2 October 1923, p. 10; The Argus, 2 October 1923, p. 9; Charles Beresford Goslett (d.1922), Brighton General Cemetery, Presbyterian Section Q, Grave 192. ↩︎
- The Age, 2 May 1924, p. 15; Annie May (Mayne) Willett (d.1924), Brighton General Cemetery, Methodist Section O, Grave 43. ↩︎
- The Age, 20 November 1930, p. 10. ↩︎
- The Argus, 30 December 1950, p. 3. ↩︎
- The Argus, 5 August 1955, p. 1. ↩︎
- South Bourke and Mornington Journal, 30 Sept 1885, p. 2. ↩︎
- The Age, 31 October 1925, p. 37; The Sun News-Pictorial, 31 October 1925, p. 10. The defendants were Henry O’Loughlin, Martin Farrell, William Brace, Albert Burrows, Frank A. Graham, Allan Henry Jackson, David Leslie, Ebenezer Morris, Geoffrey O’Loughlin, John Rowe, Bert Camm, Roy Conquest, Martin Boyle, Reginald Bell, Frederick Waite, Henry Wilson, Bert Saunders, Frederick Saunders, John Sayers, Frederick Harold Sinclair, Hector Sinclair, Alexander Somers, Robert Thomas and Reginald Turner. ↩︎
- The Age, 22 February 1930, p. 19; The Argus, 22 February 1930, p. 10. ↩︎
- The Sun News-Pictorial, 6 June 1929, p. 6; Trustee Minutes Book “B”, pp. 11-12. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “B”, p. 22. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “B”, p. 28. ↩︎
- The Age, 13 December 1927, p. 18. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “C”, pp. 33, 38 and 69. ↩︎
- The Age, 18 April 1949, p. 3; The Argus, 18 April 1949, p. 3; The Herald, 16 April 1949, p. 3. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “C”, pp. 105-120 and 129. ↩︎
- Department of Health and Community Services file “Brighton Cemetery” (93/387/18 73/1), Part II (1950-1982), F. N. Allen, Secretary, Brighton General Cemetery Trust, to Town Clerk, Caulfield City Council, 8 January 1968; P. Barnett, Acting Town Clerk, to F. N. Allen, 9 January 1968; B. Moran, Town Clerk, to F. N. Allen, 20 February and 20 March 1968. ↩︎
- Envelope marked “Application for removal of remains 1920”, Law Department, Secretary to Brighton General Cemetery, 5 August 1920, concerning application for removal of remains of E. Fairbairn; Secretary, Law Department, to Secretary, Brighton Cemetery Trustees, 19 March 1925, concerning removal of the remains of M. C. Fleming to Eastern Cemetery, Geelong, Brighton General Cemetery Trust. ↩︎
- Department of Health and Community Services file, Part I (1900-1949), C. Gill, Secretary, Brighton General Cemetery, to Secretary, Law Department, 18 March 1927; Secretary, Crown Law Department, to Chairman, Commission of Public Health, 21 March 1927; Secretary, Public Health Department, to Secretary, Law Department, 3 May 1927; Norman John Clarence Frusher (d.1925), Brighton General Cemetery, Church of England Section ZE, Grave 44; Lillian May (Lily) Frusher (d.1973), Brighton General Cemetery, Church of England Section ZE, Grave 44. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “B”, p. 353; Trustee Minutes Book “C”, pp. 4 and 42; Envelope marked “Mis-burial 1936”, correspondence and papers concerning F. Griffin and Roman Catholic grave 97R, 1935-36, Brighton General Cemetery Trust; Mary Butler (d.1921), Brighton General Cemetery, Roman Catholic Section R, Grave 97; Edward Thomas Butler (d.1933), Brighton General Cemetery, Roman Catholic Section R, Grave 97. ↩︎
- Department of Health and Community Services file “Brighton Cemetery” (93/387/18 73), Part II (1950-1992), General Health Branch memorandum concerning the funeral of Amy Annie Hall, 14 November 1974; A. T. Gardner, Secretary, Commission of Public Health, to I. R. Lovell, Chairman, Brighton Public Cemetery, 15 November 1974; I. R. Lovell to A. T. Gardner, 25 November 1974; Trustee Minutes Book “D”, pp. 112-113; Amy Anne Hall (d.1974), Brighton General Cemetery, Lawn Section L, Grave 142. ↩︎
- The Argus, 10 October 1936, p. 23. ↩︎
- The Herald, 15 July 1953, p. 1; Charles Newby Butt (d.1953) and Mary Ellen Butt (d.1953), Brighton General Cemetery, Baptist Section L, Grave 69D. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “C”, pp. 18-21. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “B”, pp. 147, 178, 184-185, 191, 210 and 218; Trustee Minutes Book “C”, pp. 3, 22, 34, 38, 54, 102, 136, 153, 167, 185, 262, 275, 291, 306, 321, 336, 348, 360 and 372. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “C”, p. 91. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes 1999, C. V. Burke to AON Risk Services, 25 May 1999, pp. 179-181; Trustee Minutes, 21 June and 2 August 1999, pp. 183-193. ↩︎
- “Underworld police swoop outside cemetery”, Sydney Morning Herald, 9 June 2004 [online]; Mark Buttler, Paul Anderson and Cameron Smith, “Four charged with murder conspiracy”, Herald Sun, 10 June 2004, p. 1; ABC News, “Court hears driver unaware co-accused was armed”, 4 August 2004; “Vic man guilty over gangland murder plot”, Sydney Morning Herald, 26 September 2007 [online]; “Gregg James Hildebrandt loses appeal on Mario Condello hit”, Herald Sun, 15 August 2008 [online]; Daniel Fogarty, “Sonnet jailed for gangland kill conspiracy”, Sydney Morning Herald, 23 March 2012 [online]. ↩︎
- Trustee Minutes Book “C”, pp. 17, 19, 155-156 and 185. ↩︎
- Envelope marked “E. Hunkin Claim”, Brighton General Cemetery Trust, concerning Edward Martin Robert Hunkin claim, including statements of B. A. W. Gales, U. M. Gales and N. Chrimes; County Court of Victoria, Edward Martin Robert Hunkin v R. Cainer, N. Alexander, M. Westlake, M. Phipps and G. Doolan, No. 466844 of 1984, Amended Statement of Claim; B. A. W. Gales to A.M.P. Society Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd, 17 October 1985; G. N. Doolan to A.M.P. Insurance Company, 30 October 1985. ↩︎
- The Argus, 25 February 1956, p. 6. ↩︎
- Herald Sun, 5 March 2015, p. 18. ↩︎
- Oral history interview with Pamela Chappell (née Walker), 7 May 1999, author’s collection; Pamela Margaret Chappell (d.2022), Brighton General Cemetery, Lawn Section C, Grave 44. ↩︎
