Chapter 31. Holding the Line

The trustees will object to the acquisition of the said land unless the compensation and requests as previously outlined are agreed to.
— Brighton General Cemetery Trust, June 1968

By the closing decades of the 20th century, maintaining Brighton General Cemetery had become a very different undertaking from developing it. The brick wall that had enclosed the cemetery since the 1920s was one of the trustees’ most persistent responsibilities, with cracks, unstable piers, damaged sections and pressure exerted by nearby trees demanding repeated inspection and repair. Roads, buildings, gates, equipment and the grounds themselves also required continuing attention. At the same time, the trustees were expected to preserve public safety and the appearance of the cemetery while declining interments reduced the income and workforce available for major works. The challenge was increasingly one of making the best use of limited resources while preserving what previous generations had created.

The cemetery boundary itself had already been altered before these later maintenance problems emerged. In 1967 Caulfield City Council proposed major works at the intersection of Hawthorn and North Roads which required part of the south-western corner of the cemetery reserve. The affected strip extended approximately 354 feet along Hawthorn Road. Although it contained no graves, the trustees regarded it as valuable future burial land and objected to its removal unless the cemetery was compensated for the resulting loss.

Figure 31.1. Caulfield City Council plan showing the proposed alteration of the Brighton General Cemetery boundary for roadworks at the intersection of Hawthorn and North Roads, 1967. Source: Department of Health and Community Services.

The trustees calculated that the roadworks would eliminate 127 potential grave sites and assessed the resulting loss of land and future revenue at $37,714.30. Their estimate took account not only of grave sites, but also anticipated income from burials, bronze plaques and flower containers, together with landscaping, maintenance, resurveying and future increases in grave prices. The Trust also expected the affected brick boundary wall to be reconstructed on the new line, trees to be removed where necessary and disturbed drainage to be restored without cost to the cemetery.

The claim for compensation encountered a fundamental obstacle. The land was Crown land reserved for cemetery purposes and administered by the trustees, and health officials concluded that the Trust was therefore not entitled to compensation if part of the reserve was transferred to another public purpose. The Commission of Public Health raised no objection to the excision, provided that paths, fences and other cemetery works were reinstated along the new boundary without cost to the trustees. In February 1969 the reservation of 13 perches as cemetery land was formally revoked. The episode represented a small but permanent contraction of the cemetery reserve: land which the trustees regarded as part of the cemetery’s future burial capacity was surrendered to the demands of the expanding suburban road network. For once, Caulfield Council had prevailed in its long-running clashes with the Cemetery Trust. Having failed decades earlier to halt the cemetery’s expansion, the council now succeeded in taking a small part of the cemetery itself for the expansion of its roads. 1

Figure 31.2. The 13-perch portion of Brighton General Cemetery excised for roadworks at the intersection of Hawthorn and North Roads, 1969. Courtesy: Victorian Government Gazette.

The old antagonism between the Cemetery Trust and Caulfield Council had by no means disappeared. While the proposed excision of cemetery land was still being negotiated, another dispute arose over trees growing along Sheffield Street. In February 1968 the trustees protested after the council refused their request to remove trees growing hard against the brick boundary fence, which they feared might damage its foundations. Secretary F. N. Allen was unusually forthright, suggesting that the council was “afraid of Newspapers and a couple of householders in the Sheffield Street area”, to the detriment of the many grave owners within the cemetery. He rejected the alternatives proposed by the council and again pressed for the trees themselves to be removed. More than forty years after the disputes over drainage, expansion and the Outer Reserve, relations between the Cemetery Trust and Caulfield Council could evidently still become decidedly combative. 2

The trustees had already begun preparing financially for such responsibilities. In November 1970 Chairman Ian R. Lovel reviewed investments with a face value of $126,600 and explained that their purpose extended beyond simply earning interest. They provided a source of ready cash in the event of major repairs and a reserve from which the day-to-day maintenance of the cemetery could be supported if ordinary income fell substantially. Lovel observed that the investments had been accumulated over approximately the previous 20 years and suggested that one of the principal reasons for creating them had been to provide income should the Trust’s general revenue eventually decline. The investment reserve was therefore already being regarded as a safeguard for the cemetery’s long-term maintenance well before the exhaustion of burial space became immediate. 3

The financial accounts of the 1970s reveal that the pressures underlying this later struggle were already developing while the cemetery remained comparatively active. Fees received for graves, monuments and interments increased from $76,678 in 1974 to $160,537 in 1980, but salaries, wages and essential works also absorbed substantial amounts. During these years the trustees continued to spend upon roads, drainage, buildings, walls, gates, machinery, lawn development and the cemetery grounds. The balance held in cash and investments declined from approximately $130,076 at the end of 1974 to $93,011 at the end of 1979, before recovering to $102,551 in 1980. The accounts therefore depict a cemetery that was still generating substantial burial income, but was simultaneously carrying the growing cost of maintaining and extending an ageing institution.

New grave sales and interments remained relatively strong during this period. Between 1974 and 1980 the cemetery recorded between 301 and 377 burials annually, while sales of new grave sites ranged from 91 to 131 a year. This continuing demand explains why the trustees were still developing lawn areas, altering roads and purchasing equipment. It also reveals the approaching difficulty. Much of the cemetery’s income remained dependent upon activity that required available burial space. Once the supply of new graves diminished, the Trust would retain the cost of maintaining the cemetery without being able to rely upon the same continuing stream of grave sales and interment fees. 4

Faced with rising maintenance costs, the trustees also sought additional income directly from grave holders. An annual maintenance charge for lawn graves was introduced in 1976 to provide more frequent mowing and trimming around plaques than could be achieved through the cemetery’s ordinary maintenance programme. The arrangement soon caused confusion. In March 1977 a grave holder complained to the Commission of Public Health after unexpectedly receiving an account for $12.50, questioning whether the charge was compulsory and expressing concern about its effect upon pensioners and others who had purchased graves without anticipating an annual fee. The cemetery subsequently acknowledged that some accounts had inadvertently been sent without the explanatory memorandum intended to accompany them. Despite the controversy, when the trustees reviewed their Scale of Fees in June they specifically resolved that the “Lawn Graves Maintenance fee remain as at present”.

The controversy widened later that year when the Australian Funeral Directors’ Association objected “in the strongest possible terms”, arguing that families were effectively being asked to pay again for maintenance they believed had already been included in the original purchase price. The Commission of Public Health confirmed that approval of the maintenance scheme had been given on the understanding that participation was optional. In September 1977 the trustees were required to amend the published scale of fees to make its voluntary nature clear, with the Commission warning that otherwise the maintenance charges could be removed from the approved schedule. The trustees’ justification was not simply financial. Secretary Frank Allen explained that the charge was intended to help retain staff and maintain the frequency of lawn mowing, while indicating that arrangements could be made where payment caused hardship. This flexibility continued under Brian Gales, who reported in 1980 that reduced contributions were accepted from people unable to meet the full charge, with pensioners paying half the standard amount. The dispute illustrated the increasingly difficult balance facing the Trust: maintaining the cemetery was becoming more expensive, but attempts to recover those costs from grave holders risked creating the impression that families were being charged twice for the continuing care of graves. 5

Brighton’s approaching closure formed part of a much wider concern about the future maintenance of Victoria’s older cemeteries. In 1983 the Cemeteries and Crematoria Working Party recommended that Brighton and thirteen other cemeteries be closed to further burials as soon as practicable, except where rights of burial had already been sold. The Working Party recognised, however, that closure would cause a loss of revenue to the affected cemetery trusts while responsibility for maintaining their grounds continued. It therefore recommended government financial assistance for the following fifty years, citing declining trust revenue and, in many cases, inadequate financial reserves.

The problem remained unresolved as attention turned to the future administration of Victoria’s cemeteries. In 1984 the Mortuary Industry and Cemeteries Administration Committee recommended that municipal councils replace most existing cemetery trusts. The Municipal Association of Victoria opposed transferring that responsibility without corresponding State funding, warning that many trusts were already experiencing difficulty maintaining their cemeteries and that the situation could only worsen as cemeteries closed and lost their principal source of revenue while maintenance obligations remained. Its assessment was blunt: “A closed cemetery will be a financial liability for a municipality.” The debate identified precisely the problem Brighton now faced: the exhaustion of burial space did not remove the continuing cost of maintaining the cemetery. 6

By 1987 the effects of the Closing Order were becoming increasingly apparent in the cemetery’s finances and staffing. New grave sales had virtually ceased, while the trustees were deliberately building investment reserves against the cost of maintaining the cemetery in future years. Investment holdings had reached $272,980 by the end of 1986 and continued to increase, while falling burial numbers prompted a progressive reduction of the permanent workforce to four employees, supplemented by casual labour when required. The Trust was therefore already putting into practice the strategy it would later describe in its 1997 submission: reducing operating costs while accumulating reserves capable of supporting a cemetery whose traditional sources of income were disappearing. 7

One form of interment nevertheless increased markedly as the supply of ordinary new graves disappeared. Stillborn children had occasionally been buried in Presbyterian Section D since the 19th century, but from the mid-1980s the pattern changed substantially. On 30 June 1986 eight stillborn children were interred in Grave 66, the first recorded occasion on which five or more were placed in the same grave on the same day. Thereafter such communal interments became characteristic of the section: 179 stillborn children were interred there during the 1980s, 803 during the 1990s and 811 during the 2000s, with more than 90 per cent in each of those decades belonging to batches of five or more. The cemetery’s own annual reports reflect this changing practice. By 1989 the trustees were recording “BABY PUBLIC” burials, and the following year’s report separately identified “PUBLIC BABY” and “PUBLIC ADULTS”. Stillborn burials were concentrated principally in Presbyterian D and later in the public or common ground of Independent B, allowing this form of burial to continue even as conventional new grave space elsewhere in the cemetery had virtually disappeared. 8

Figure 31.3. A visitor among the stillborn children’s graves in Presbyterian Section D, 23 June 2015. From the mid-1980s this area was extensively used for communal stillborn interments. Photograph: author’s collection.

The Closing Order had not brought the institution to an end. More than a decade later the trustees could point to the fact that Brighton had continued to operate independently and produce annual surpluses despite its inability to develop new burial ground. In their January 1997 submission to the review of the Cemeteries Act, they argued that closure had forced substantial efficiencies in both expenditure and revenue raising. Investments which stood at $132,000 when the Closing Order took effect had increased to $611,000, with the trustees deliberately seeking to build a reserve whose interest could compensate for the decline in income from conventional cemetery operations. 9

But the trustees did not regard financial survival as an end in itself. They argued that the public expected the cemetery to remain maintained and accessible, while Brighton also contained graves and monuments possessing historical and architectural significance which had to be preserved for future generations. Their opposition to privatisation and their support for reform of grave tenure were therefore closely related: both were presented as means of ensuring that a cemetery which could no longer expand would nevertheless retain the resources necessary to care for what was already there. 10

The trustees nevertheless understood how precarious that independence might become. Their 1997 submission warned that declining income would eventually overtake the cemetery’s resources and argued for the introduction of limited tenure as a means of restoring burial capacity and future revenue. At the same time, they insisted that any reuse of graves would have to recognise historical significance, religious requirements and the expectations of families, reserving the right to preserve graves which ought not to be disturbed. The problem confronting Brighton was therefore no longer simply how to find another grave site, but how to keep a closed historic cemetery financially and physically sustainable without destroying the character that made it worth preserving. 11

The effort to maintain the cemetery with diminishing resources extended beyond its buildings and boundary walls to the workforce itself. By 1996 the permanent outdoor staff had been reduced to three employees, supplemented when necessary by casual labour, while the Secretary-Manager was also required to maintain the office. The small workforce created particular difficulties when rostered days off coincided. Rather than immediately appoint additional permanent staff, the trustees agreed to trial closing the cemetery to burials on one Friday each month when the outdoor employees took their rostered day off. The arrangement demonstrated the increasingly fine balance between maintaining sufficient staff to operate the cemetery and containing the cost of doing so. 12

Operating with fewer employees also required clearer lines of responsibility. In August 1996 the trustees considered difficulties that had arisen when outdoor employees approached the Chairman directly with workplace matters rather than dealing through the Secretary-Manager. The ensuing discussion reaffirmed the Manager’s authority over the staff and the need for an established chain of command. Later that year the two full-time outdoor employees were reclassified as Uncertificated Grave Diggers so that employees performing the same work received the same award rate. The episode was comparatively minor, but it illustrates the administrative adjustments required to keep a small workforce functioning effectively when there were few employees available to absorb disagreements, absences or changing duties. 13

The structural problems had already been developing for almost a decade. In 1987 cracking at the north-west corner was being monitored for movement, and the following year the trustees recorded that no movement “of any consequence” had occurred. By 1991 a large crack in the Sheffield Road wall required repair, while in 1992-93 part of the south-eastern boundary became unsafe. A section was demolished and an old cypress removed before repairs could proceed. The extensive cracking identified in 1996 was therefore not an isolated episode, but the continuation of a problem the trustees had been monitoring and repairing for years. 14

In 1996 the condition of the boundary had again become sufficiently serious for the trustees to consider whether continuing repairs remained the best course. Six piers in the Hawthorn Road wall were described as being in disrepair, with movement and large cracking attributed to the absence of expansion joints in the original construction. Three piers in Sheffield Street were similarly affected. Repairs were estimated at $12,000 and $6,000 respectively. When the trustees considered the programme of major works in March, the possibility of replacing rather than repairing the wall was raised, although it was thought that complete replacement might cost as much as the continuing repairs. A subcommittee was appointed to inspect the wall, gates and roads and determine priorities. 15

The problem was not regarded as one capable of a single repair campaign. The trustees’ programme for 1997 described damaged wall piers as requiring continuing assessment and explicitly identified repair of the wall as an “ongoing project”. The boundary had therefore become a permanent maintenance liability rather than an occasional building repair, competing with roads, gates, buildings and other works for the cemetery’s limited resources. 16

The continuing demands of the boundary eventually attracted outside financial assistance. In March 2001 Glen Eira Council announced that more than $60,000, comprising part grant and part loan funding from the Melbourne Heritage Restoration Fund, had been obtained for restoration of the cemetery’s North Road entrance. The work was directed specifically at the brick pillars and wrought-iron panels forming the semi-circular entrance. Cemetery Manager Chris Burke welcomed the assistance, describing Brighton Cemetery as having “great historical and cultural significance for the local area”, while the Council presented the restoration as the protection and enhancement of an important public asset. The works were expected to be completed in April. The project marked a significant development in the continuing maintenance of the cemetery’s fabric: preservation of the boundary was no longer solely a matter of repairing deteriorating brickwork as problems arose, but had also become an issue of conserving a recognised element of Brighton’s heritage. 17

Recognition of that character was becoming more formal. During the later 1990s the cemetery was drawn into heritage studies and planning controls, while the trustees themselves confronted the consequences of caring for historic buildings and monuments within a restricted budget. By 2000 the Glen Eira heritage overlay was proceeding for the residence and the Miller mausoleum. The cemetery was increasingly being managed not simply as an operating burial ground but also as a historic place whose buildings, graves, landscape and records carried obligations of preservation. 18

References:

  1. Department of Health and Community Services file “Brighton Cemetery” (93/387/18 73), Part II (1950-1992), correspondence and departmental memoranda concerning the proposed excision of cemetery land for reconstruction of the Hawthorn Road and North Road intersection, 1967-68, City of Caulfield Town Clerk to Secretary, Brighton General Cemetery Trust, 17 October 1967; Victorian Government Gazette, 12 February 1969, p. 296. ↩︎
  2. Department of Health and Community Services file, Part II (1950-1992), F. N. Allen, Secretary, Brighton General Cemetery Trust, to Town Clerk, Caulfield City Council, 4 February 1968. ↩︎
  3. Envelope marked “SEC Stock Correspondence”, I. R. Lovel, “Report on Investments of Brighton General Cemetery”, 9 November 1970, Brighton General Cemetery Trust. ↩︎
  4. Brighton General Cemetery, Abstracts of Accounts and supporting statements, 1974-80, Health Department Cemeteries and Crematoria file, pp. 2-17. ↩︎
  5. Department of Health and Community Services file, Part II (1950-1992), correspondence concerning annual grave maintenance charges, 1977, including complaint to Commission of Public Health, 18 March 1977; Brighton General Cemetery to grave holder, 25 March 1977; Australian Funeral Directors’ Association to Minister of Health, 29 August 1977; Commission of Public Health, “Brighton General Cemetery”, 6 September 1977; F. N. Allen to M. B. Hildrebrandt, 15 January 1977; B. A. W. Gales to A. Joseph, Health Commission of Victoria, 25 June 1980; Brighton General Cemetery Trustee Minutes Book “D”, p. 218. ↩︎
  6. Department of Health and Community Services file, Part II (1950-1992), Municipal Association of Victoria, Circular MAV40/83, “Cemeteries and Crematoria Working Party”, 22 March 1983; Mortuary Industry and Cemeteries Administration Committee, Second Report, “The Administration of Cemeteries in Victoria”, 1984; Municipal Association of Victoria, Circular MAV102/84, “Report on the Management of Public Cemeteries in Victoria – Its Implications for Local Government”, 21 August 1984. ↩︎
  7. Trustee Minutes Book “E”, pp. 21, 29-30 and 35; Department of Health and Community Services file “Brighton Cemetery” (93/387/18 73/2), Part III (1985-1992), Health Department inspection material concerning Brighton General Cemetery, 1987. ↩︎
  8. Brighton General Cemetery burial records, analysis of stillborn interments in Presbyterian Section D and Independent Section B; Trustee Minutes Book “E”, pp. 29, 34-35 and 41. ↩︎
  9. Trustee Minutes 1997, Brighton Cemetery Trustees’ submission to the Cemeteries Act Review, 21 January 1997, pp. 51-53. ↩︎
  10. Trustee Minutes 1997, pp. 51-53. ↩︎
  11. Trustee Minutes 1997, pp. 52-53. ↩︎
  12. Brighton General Cemetery Trustee Minutes 1996, “Minimum staff requirements”, p. 25; Minutes, 20 May 1996, pp. 31-32. ↩︎
  13. Trustee Minutes 1996, Minutes, 12 August 1996, pp. 39-41; Minutes, 9 December 1996, pp. 48-50. ↩︎
  14. Trustee Minutes Book “E”, pp. 18, 21, 48, 54 and 56-57. ↩︎
  15. Trustee Minutes 1996, “Major projects to be undertaken and placed in order of priority”, pp. 14-15; Minutes, 18 March 1996, pp. 16-18. ↩︎
  16. Trustee Minutes 1997, “Projects 1997 and Beyond”, pp. 60-63. ↩︎
  17. Glen Eira Council, “Heritage Funding for the Brighton Cemetery”, media release, 5 March 2001. ↩︎
  18. Trustee Minutes 1996, Minutes, 14 October 1996, pp. 42-43; Trustee Minutes 1997, Correspondence and Manager’s Report, 1997 and 1998; Trustee Minutes 2000, Manager’s Report, 10 February 2000, p. 219. ↩︎